All Religious-Based Answers Are Acceptable?

Roadside Musings

All Religious-Based Answers Are Acceptable?

kevron2001/Getty Images

“If the students in Ohio schools want to replace math with myth, and fact with fiction, who am I to judge?”

Jesus said, “When you know the truth, the truth will set you free” (John 8:32). Clearly Jesus never lived in Ohio. The Ohio House of Representatives has just passed The Student Religious Liberties Act, a bill that forbids teachers from penalizing students who give wrong answers to questions as long as those answers are upheld by the student’s religious beliefs. Specifics were not given but one can easily imagine school test questions such as the following:

1) What role to Jews play in the world?

a) Christ Killers

b) Spawn of Satan

c) Betrayers of God

d) All of the above

2) What, if any, are examples of legitimate uses of capital punishment?

a) Murder

b) Homosexuality

c) Picking up sticks on a Saturday

d) All of the above

3) When was the earth created?

a) 4.54 billion years ago

b) 5,780 years ago

c) 6,000 years ago

d) Oct. 23, 4004 BCE

Actually, I have no problem with this bill as long as it is applied uniformly. For example,

1) Who is the One True God?

a) Christ

b) Krishna

c) Flying Spaghetti Monster

d) All of the above

If all religious based answers are acceptable, then I’m fine with the new law. Of course, if a student were to write in, “There is no God” that would be a wrong answer since atheism is not a religion but a rejection of religion. This prejudice against atheists doesn’t bother me because by the time this bill becomes law every atheist will have moved out the state.

The rationale behind The Student Religious Liberties Act seems to be that religious kids are snowflakes who cannot take having their beliefs questioned. Fair enough. More and more Americans are snowflakes on an ever-growing number of issues, so what’s one more?

Of course, if religious answers are as valid as scientific answers students in Ohio will have a hard time going to out-of-state graduate schools. When asked to name the primary cause of Hurricane Katrina, the Ohio student who answers “sin” is being true to her faith but will still make a lousy climate scientist. And I wouldn’t want to learn earth science from an Indian professor who got her doctorate from the University of Ohio affirming the earth rests on the back of Akupara, a giant turtle.

Or am I being too narrow-minded? In our age of fake news and alternative facts who is to say the earth doesn’t rest on the back of a huge tortoise? You know what? Not me. Now that I think of it, if the students in Ohio schools want to replace math with myth, and fact with fiction, who am I to judge? No, let Ohio be Ohio. I’m just proud to have been educated in Massachusetts. At least there we only burn witches.

Check out more of Rabbi Rami’s thought-provoking and often hilarious writings, here.

Roadside Musings

In Roadside Musings, Rabbi Rami draws from the well of the world's religious and spiritual...
Read More

Continue your journey

Enjoying this content?

Get this article and many more delivered straight to your inbox weekly.